Blog

Why Colleges are Struggling with Student Retention in Higher Education

3 higher ed students, walking outside, each holding a mobile device
course_review_1.jpg

Table of Contents

 

Roughly three in 10 students who started college in fall 2024 weren't enrolled at the same school a year later. The National Student Clearinghouse Research Center (NSC) reported in June 2026 that 69.1% of that cohort stayed at their starting institution, and about 23% weren't enrolled anywhere. Student retention in higher education is moving higher on the list of pressing challenges universities face because those losses now land on a shrinking pool of new students.

Retention is also the challenge where an institution already holds a lot of the information it needs; a student who leaves often shows signs first. Here are four reasons retention deserves a plan now, followed by the college student retention strategies institutions are using to keep more of the students they already have.

1. The pool of new students is getting smaller

The Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education (WICHE) projected in its December 2024 Knocking at the College Door report that US high school graduates would peak at about 3.9 million in 2025. After that, WICHE expects a steady decline to 3.4 million by 2041, a 13% drop, with most states losing graduates.

For institutions that budget around steady first-year classes, that projection puts more weight on the students already enrolled. Every student who leaves after the first year is harder to replace when the next incoming class is drawn from a smaller group.

2. Why students drop out of college often starts outside the classroom

Students who think about leaving point first to stress, mental health, and money.

The Lumina Foundation and Gallup State of Higher Education 2026 study surveyed 6,010 currently enrolled students in October 2025. One in three (33%) had considered stopping out or withdrawing in the past six months. The most common reasons were emotional stress (46%), mental health (38%), and cost of attendance (28%), according to NCAN's summary of the report. That share is down from a peak of 41% in 2022, but it's still one student in three.

Understanding this list shapes how institutions can respond. Since none of the top reasons are academic at the core, a tutoring referral alone won't reach most of these students. Stress and money problems also don't generate a form the registrar sees. Where they can surface early is inside a course, in a steady stream of late submissions or a sizeable login gap, which is why so much retention work now starts with course data.

3. The gaps are widest for part-time students

Retention rates vary a lot depending on who the student is and how they enroll. Part-time students show the biggest gap: fewer than half of the fall 2024 part-time cohort were still at their starting school a year later.

One year after starting college: fall 2024 cohort

Student group

Persistence (enrolled at any school)

Retention (same school)

All students

77%

69.1%

Part-time students

54.1%

48.0%

Native American students

65.7%

56.5%

Black students

70.0%

59.6%

Hispanic students

74.5%

66.9%

Source: National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, June 2026

The same report carries good news. Rates for Black, Hispanic, and part-time students reached their highest levels in a decade. Even so, retention for part-time students still trails the overall rate by about 21 points.

A part-time student usually has less room in the week to move things around when something goes wrong. Courses built around a full-time schedule, with live-only sessions or deadlines stacked midweek, ask the most of the students who have the least slack.

4. Advisors can't reach every student in time

Tyton Partners' Driving Toward a Degree 2025 study surveyed more than 3,000 people across 825-plus US institutions. Only 29% of students reported using academic advising. More than 70% of large and public institutions are increasing advisor caseloads, and Tyton identifies heavy caseloads as the biggest obstacle to effective advising.

Put those numbers next to the NSC data and advising offices are being asked to catch more at-risk students with less time for each one, and waiting for students to come in doesn't work well when about seven in 10 don't report using advising at all.

Which college student retention strategies are institutions using?

Improving student retention rates usually comes down to seeing trouble sooner and making help easier to reach. Here's where institutions are putting that effort.

  • Catching disengagement early. Course activity like skipped discussion posts and unopened readings can flag a student early in the term. Read more about how early alert systems in higher ed use LMS data.
  • Sending alerts to people who can act. With caseloads rising, a flag that sits in one instructor's dashboard reaches too few people. Alerts work best when they reach advisors and support staff with enough context to follow up.
  • Putting support where students already are. In Instructure's 2023 global research with Hanover Research, 47% of institutions reported providing mental health resources through their learning management system. When stress and mental health top the list of reasons students consider leaving, a counseling link inside the course is closer than a page on the student services site.
  • Designing courses for students with less slack. Clear module structure, predictable deadlines, and flexible pacing where the program allows it make it easier for part-time and working students to stay on track.
  • Showing students where they stand. Students who can check their own grades and progress know have a map to getting caught up without anyone needing tell them.

See how one tribal college raised retention with Canvas

Red Lake Nation College in Red Lake, Minnesota, moved to Canvas by Instructure in fall 2017 alongside three other tribal colleges. Faculty used Canvas to monitor assignments, quizzes, and test scores, and students could check their own grades at any time. The college reported semester-to-semester retention rising from between 60% and 70% to 80%.

"I've seen a big change in the motivation of students. They're more accountable for their education because they know they have the independence to check their grades, and they're not relying on having to see their teachers face-to-face to get that feedback." - Cassy Leeport, Director of Library Services and Tribal Archives at Red Lake Nation College.

Check out the full case study to find out more about how Red Lake Nation College helped students and advisors track progress in real time and raised semester-to-semester retention. 

Frequently asked questions

What is student retention in higher education? Student retention is the share of students who stay enrolled at the same institution from one year to the next. The NSC also tracks persistence, which counts students enrolled at any institution. For students who started in fall 2024, NSC reported 69.1% retention and 77% persistence.

What are the most common reasons students consider leaving college? In the Lumina Foundation and Gallup State of Higher Education 2026 study, students who had considered stopping out most often cited emotional stress (46%), mental health (38%), and cost of attendance (28%).

What student retention challenges do universities face? Universities are working against a shrinking pipeline, with WICHE projecting 13% fewer high school graduates by 2041. They also face wide gaps for part-time students, whose same-school retention was 48.0% for the fall 2024 cohort, and stretched advising teams, with more than 70% of large and public institutions increasing caseloads, per Tyton Partners.

How can universities start improving student retention rates? Many start with data they already have. Course activity in the learning management system can flag disengagement early, support resources can live inside courses, and alerts can go to advisors who have time to follow up.

About the Author

Sr. Manager, Content Marketing, Instructure

Marianne Chrisos is the Sr. Manager, Content Marketing at Instructure, where she focuses on strategic storytelling and amplifying the voices of educators and learners. With a healthy obsession with how words move people and a lifelong curiosity, she’s excited to share stories and conversations on AI in the classroom, experiential learning, edtech innovation, the science of learning, and creativity across education. She lives and works outside of Chicago, where she spends her free time reading, watching Star Trek, gardening, adopting cats, powerlifting, and getting tattoos.

Like what you learned?

Stay in the know by subscribing to monthly recaps of our news feed.

CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.